Stuck replaying the same thoughts over and over?
If you find yourself constantly going over past events with a hefty dose of self-criticism – “I could have done this, I should have said that” – you’re dealing with rumination, and it’s incredibly common among perfectionists.
Learning how to stop rumination is crucial because this habit of repetitively mulling over thoughts or problems without ever reaching a resolution can seriously impact your mental health and daily functioning. If this sounds painfully familiar, I’ve got you covered.
Before we dive into practical strategies to stop rumination, let’s discuss why breaking this cycle should be an absolute priority.
Why You Need to Stop Rumination: The Hidden Costs
Some people actually believe rumination is helpful – they think it means they’re analysing their feelings or that going over events will help them understand what happened and why. They assume covering all possible angles is the best way to solve problems.
But here’s the truth: rumination doesn’t help in any way. In fact, it’s actively harmful.
Research shows that rumination:
- Makes you think more negatively, especially about yourself
- Increases negative mood and significantly increases risk for depression
- Intensifies and prolongs existing depression
- Seriously interferes with problem-solving abilities and impairs concentration
- Impairs your ability to think clearly and process emotions effectively
- Is strongly associated with low mood, reduced energy and motivation, procrastination, and decreased activity
The cruel irony? When you ruminate, you’re trying to reduce distress and overcome problems, but you actually end up increasing and prolonging your distress while making the original problem feel much bigger.
As well as interfering with clear thinking, daily functioning, and your ability to cope, rumination often leads to unhelpful behaviours like self-harm, excessive drinking, substance use, and emotional eating.
Rumination vs. Worry: Understanding the Difference
Although they often occur together, it can be incredibly helpful to distinguish between rumination and worry when you’re learning to stop rumination:
Worry is future-focused: Imagining the worst-case scenarios, thinking “what if?” about potential risks and challenges that haven’t happened yet.
Rumination is past-focused: Constantly chewing over things that have already happened, regurgitating and repeatedly thinking about the same events or conversations. It’s often characterised by regret with a heavy emphasis on personal failures.
Rumination sounds like: “If only I had…”, “I should have…”, “I shouldn’t have…” playing on repeat in your mind. These thoughts keep returning relentlessly, and it becomes incredibly difficult to break the cycle.
How to Stop Rumination: A Step-by-Step Approach
Step 1: Develop Awareness That You’re Ruminating
The first crucial step to stop rumination is becoming aware that you’re doing it and genuinely recognising that it isn’t helpful. Increased self-awareness is absolutely essential.
You cannot shift out of rumination unless you start noticing when it begins. This part requires lots of practice, but the more you notice when rumination starts, the quicker you’ll become at catching it in real-time.
Step 2: Identify Your Personal Rumination Triggers
Learning to recognise what specifically sets off your rumination means you can intervene much sooner and break the cycle more effectively.
Common rumination triggers include:
- Specific times of day (often evenings or when you’re alone)
- Particular emotions (feeling disappointed, embarrassed, or frustrated)
- Certain environments or situations
- Specific types of events (social interactions, work presentations, etc.)
Step 3: Make a Conscious Decision to Interrupt the Pattern
Once you notice rumination happening, make a deliberate choice to “ban” the rumination and actively work to stop rumination in that moment.
Of course, this is much easier said than done. My top strategy is to find an effective distraction that genuinely captures your attention. Focus elsewhere for at least ten minutes to help interrupt the rumination cycle. You’ll quickly learn which specific distractions work most effectively for your mind.
5 Proven Strategies to Stop Rumination
Here are five additional evidence-based techniques you can try when you find yourself caught in rumination:
1. Practice Self-Compassion
Consider what you would say to a close friend in the same situation. This can help you start treating yourself more compassionately. Just as you would with a friend, practise forgiving yourself if you’ve made a mistake or done something you regret.
2. Reframe the Situation
See if you can find something amusing about the situation – humour can help you view things from a completely different perspective and move forward. Try viewing what happened as a valuable learning experience, which helps you approach the situation constructively while looking toward the future. You could even try stepping back and viewing the situation as if you’re watching a scene in a film.
3. Accept Your Current Reality
Pain and suffering intensify dramatically depending on how you think about them. We feel sad because we feel sad, angry because we feel angry, and so on. Learn to feel your feelings fully, accept your current emotional state as it is, and try to stop desperately wanting things to be different.
4. Ground Yourself in the Present Moment
Use mindfulness meditation to focus your attention on your breath instead of being completely attached to your thoughts and caught up in the rumination spiral. Present-moment awareness is one of the most effective ways to stop rumination.
5. Schedule “Rumination Time” (If All Else Fails)
If you absolutely cannot stop rumination in the moment, make a conscious decision to postpone it. Plan to ruminate for 20 minutes later – perhaps after lunch or when you’ve finished work. Once you’ve scheduled specific time for ruminating later, you don’t have to stay caught up in those thoughts right now. In the meantime, engage in an activity that will genuinely capture your attention and help you feel better.
Breaking Free: You Can Stop Rumination for Good
It’s absolutely true that the more we ruminate, the stronger this mental habit becomes, and the harder it is to change. But here’s the encouraging news: the less we ruminate, the weaker the habit becomes.
You can start moving in this positive direction today. Every time you successfully interrupt rumination or choose a different response, you’re literally rewiring your brain to default to healthier thinking patterns.
Professional Support to Stop Rumination
Sometimes the most effective way to stop rumination completely is to work with a therapist who understands the specific patterns that keep you stuck. Cognitive behavioural therapy has been proven highly effective for breaking rumination cycles.
If you’re struggling to stop rumination on your own and it’s significantly impacting your daily life, professional support can provide you with personalised strategies and tools. You’re welcome to get in touch and book an initial therapy appointment here.
Useful Links
💌 Thriving Perfectionist Diaries – Thought-provoking insights and gentle mindset shifts to help you embrace high standards while feeling calm and in control. Sign up here.
